.jpg)
Satyamev Jayate (English: Truth Alone Prevails) is an Indian
television talk show that airs on various channels within Star Network along with
Doordarshan's DD National. The first season of the show premiered on May 6,
2012 and marked the television debut of popular Bollywood actor and filmmaker
Aamir Khan. While Hindi is the primary language of the show, it is also dubbed
and simulcast in other Indian languages such as Bengali, Malayalam, Marathi,
Tamil and Telugu.
Satyamev Jayate received positive response and feedback from
both the critics as well as the public. The show was widely appreciated by
several film and television personalities, politicians and social activists for
its research, format, presentation and content. The show has highlighted sensitive
social issues prevalent in India such as female foeticides, child sexual abuse,
dowry, medical malpractice, honor killings, insensitivity towards the
physically disabled, domestic violence, overuse of pesticides leading to
pesticide poisoning, alcoholism, untouchability, plight of senior citizens and
water crisis.
.jpg)
.jpg)
1. Daughters are precious (Female
foeticide in India) 6 May 2012
The first episode focused on the issue of female foeticide in India. The show began with some stories of mothers who struggled to give birth to their girl child. The first guest on the show was Amisha Yagnik from Ahmedabad. Yagnik was forced by her husband and in-laws to abort her female unborn children six times in a span of eight years and further shared her experiences in finally giving birth to a daughter. The second guest, Parveen Khan from Morena, Madhya Pradesh shared the story of her husband disfiguring her face by biting it, when she insisted on giving birth to a female child against his wishes. Another guest, doctor Mitu Khurana from Delhi was asked by her orthopaedic surgeon husband and in-laws to abort her girl twins 20 weeks after conceiving. Her story helped dispel the perception and myth among people that the abhorrent practice of female foeticide is practiced only by rural people or those living in small towns or is confined only to lesser educated people.
The show claimed that according to 2011 Census, the rate at
which the unborn female child is killed amounts to killing off 10,00,000 girls
a year and there were 914 girls for every 1,000 boys. The episode concluded
with a song "O Ri Chiraiya" sung by Swanand Kirkire along with Ram
Sampath.
Impact
On the next day after the episode went on air, Rajasthan
Chief Minister, Ashok Gehlot urged the public representatives and other
non-governmental organisations to take actions to stop the illegal practice of
female foeticide. An official reported that Gehlot also reviewed existing
efforts taken by the government against the issue. He also directed the
officials to prepare a plan for a special campaign against female foeticide.
Khan, as promised on the show, met Gehlot over the issue of
female foeticide. Gehlot accepted the request to set up fast track court to
deal the case of the sting operation featured on the show, which was conducted
in 2005 by Meena Sharma and Shripal Shaktawat. After discussion with Gehlot,
Chief Justice of the Rajasthan High Court Arun Kumar Mishra given permission to
set up the fast track court. The sting operation had revealed the faces of more
than 140 doctors involved in the illegal practices of sex determination test
and abortion. But no one had been punished in the case even after seven years.
On May 10, 2012, The Rajasthan Government suspended the
licenses of six sonography centres and issued notices to 24 others for
violating the provisions of the Pre-Conception and Pre-Natal and Diagnostic
(PCPNDT) Act, 1994. However, the health minister of Rajasthan, Rajkumar Sharma,
criticized the show for "sensationalising female foeticide cases". He
argued that the government had already been taking action against female
foetecide, and did not perform a knee-jerk reaction following the show.
The first episode of the show also had an impact on several
state governments in India. Maharashtra Health Minister, Suresh Shetty asked
for Khan's support for the government's campaign against female foeticide. In a
letter written to Khan, Shetty mentioned that the Maharashtra government had
registered cases against 317 sonography centres in the state conducting
unauthorized sex determination tests. Also 27 doctors and four families who
sought sex determination tests have been punished under the PCPNDT Act.
However, bollywood actor couple Ajay Devgn and Kajol became associated with the
government's campaign against female foeticide. Haryana government made it
compulsory to submit identification proof of the pregnant woman at ultrasonography
centres as a pre-condition for undergoing the prenatal sex discernment test.
Haryana government also announced a reward of 21,000 (US$380.1) to those who
give information about doctors conducting sex determination tests in the state.
The Government of Madhya Pradesh had suspended licence of 65 Medical
termination of pregnancy (MTP) centres in the state.
2. Break the Silence Child
sexual abuse 13 May 2012
.jpg)
The episode also included a workshop for children to create
awareness about the subject amongst children and their parents. The children
were told that there are three "danger zones" (private parts) on
everyone's body. These include the chest, area between the legs and the bottom.
The children were advised to shout and run to a safe place, and immediately
inform a person whom they trust (preferably parents) in case any unwanted
person tries to touch them in these areas.
Impact
Following the broadcast of the second episode, the helpline
for children received an increased number of calls from different cities of the
country, reporting different sorts of child abuse (both sexual abuse of children
and other forms of abuse).
On 22 May 2012, The legislation to protect children below 18
years from sexual abuse became a reality with the Lok Sabha passing the bill
which was earlier cleared by the Rajya Sabha. Child rights activists have
however called the bill regressive, and teens across the country are generally
appalled by the bill.
3. Marriage or Marketplace (Dowry
system in India) 20 May 2012
.jpg)
The third episode focused on the Dowry system in India. Khan
spoke with several women who had faced dowry harassment by their in-laws before
and after marriage. It showcased the story of Komal Sethi from New Delhi who
was married to a software professional. Her in-laws demanded furniture, cars,
jewelry, home appliances and cash from her family during and after the wedding.
After her husband got a job opportunity in the USA she was forced to ask for
money from her parents so that her husband could buy the travel tickets to USA
and a car there. Once in the US, her husband tortured her to get the legal
rights to her house in India. Upon her refusal, he physically abused her and
left her without food and water, confining her in their apartment for four days
before she was rescued by a women's care helpline.
Apart from Komal's story, the episode showcased several
stories where the women had to face similar abuse and demands including forced
plastic surgery, some of which had ended with divorce or lawsuits which are
still pending judgement. The episode also showcased the story of Rani Tripathi
from Mumbai who fought back against the dowry system by recording the dowry
demands by the groom's parents with a hidden camera. Once she informed the
media about the tape it was showcased in major TV channels across India. Her
efforts and courage was appreciated by Khan.
The show was concluded by audience opinions and the episode
song Rupaiyya composed by Ram Sampath and performed by Sona Mohapatra.
4. Every Life is Precious Medical
malpractice 27 May 2012
.jpg)
The fourth episode of the show threw light on the frail
health care system prevalent in the country. The show started with the story of
VS Venkatesh who went through four surgeries to cure an infection in his leg.
He later learnt that the entire process that had cost him 2 lakh (US$3,600) was
unnecessary and the infection could have been treated with medicines. Next,
Arvind Kumar from Hyderabad shared that he was hospitalized in an ICU for three
days and later advised a surgery when all he needed was a dose of ORS. The
episode showcased the tragic tale of Major Pankaj Rai’s wife Seema who was
suffering from a kidney ailment and lost her life when the doctors forcibly
operated on her for kidney and pancreas transplant without her family’s consent.
While the surgery cost Rai 8.25 lakh (US$14,900) and the loss of his wife, the
doctors were not bothered to inform the family about her demise and switched
off their mobile phones. Dr Anil Pichad from Mumbai who owns a pathology lab
revealed that he used to overcharge patients for tests as he had to pay
commission to the doctors. But after he went through a personal tragedy, he
stopped bribing the doctors and charges only nominal fees. Several women from
Kowdipally village in Andhra Pradesh were forced to undergo operations to get
their uterus removed. The farmers sold their lands or took loans to meet the
high costs of these operations which were not needed at all.
The show also shed light on a number of other such medical
cases where patients suffering from minor ailments were recommended to undergo
surgeries on the pretext of extracting more money from them. Khan spoke to Dr
KK Talwar, Chairman, Board of Governors, Medical Council of India (MCI), a
statutory body regulating medical colleges, affiliation, new colleges, and
doctors’ registration, to understand their actions to tackle such frauds. Dr
Talwar committed Khan and the people of the country to take actions against
such corrupt doctors. Khan read out the statistics of the percentage of doctors
in England whose licenses were permanently cancelled in the past 3 years, and
according to the RTI filed by Khan and his team, not even a single doctor's
licence has been cancelled in the recent past in the country, thus letting the
corrupt doctors off scot free. Khan also spoke to retired Major General Som
Jhingon, ex-chairman, MCI, who had resigned from his post as he was completely
disillusioned by the way the organization was functioning.
Khan, with the help of Dr. Shamit Sharma from Rajasthan, enlightened
viewers by informing them about generic medicines that are available at
affordable cost and are in no way inferior to the branded medicines produced by
celebrated pharmaceutical companies. The show also spoke about Dr. Devi Prasad
Shetty and his noble scheme that allows poor people to get medical treatment at
affordable rates. Veteran Dr. Gulati also urged the government to prioritise
health schemes so that even the poor could lead a healthy life.
Aftermath
Highly upset with Aamir on the issues raised in the episode
4, the Indian Medical Association (IMA) has demanded an apology from Aamir Khan
and warned him of legal action if he did not do so.
However Aamir declined to apologize by saying “I am very comfortable
if they (IMA) plan to take legal action if they feel that I have done something
wrong. Of course, the courts are available for them. My answer is no, I will
not be apologizing.” He added, “I deny that I have done that (defame doctors).
I have the highest respect and regard for the medical profession.” The Indian
Medical Association of Chandigarh have strongly condemned Aamir Khan's take in
the show. But this has also brought to light the divide between government and
private doctors. Private doctors have opposed the allegation, while some of the
government doctors agree to the existence of black sheep.
The Rajya Sabha Parliamentary standing committee on Commerce
has invited Aamir Khan, who exposed malpractice in the medical sector on his
"Satyamev Jayate" TV programme, for an interaction on the issue along
with his team to share knowledge they gained while researching the episode and
to give his views on FDI in the pharmaceutical sector. On 21 June 2012, Khan
appeared before the Parliamentary panel examining FDI in the pharmaceuticals
sector and pitched for generic medicines, saying companies will continue to
make profit if they sell cheap drugs to the poor.
The Government of Karnataka has announced the opening of
‘Janatha Bazaar Generic Drug Store’, a chain of medical stores, so as to sell
generic drugs at subsidised rates, almost 50% less than the MRP. According to
the sources, the stores will sell both generic and branded medicines authorised
by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, surgical equipment and orthopaedic
implants at 50 per cent of MRP. The government has also plans to make it
mandatory for all government doctors to prescribe only generic drugs.
Previously, the Government of Maharashtra had also announced plans to take
steps to make generic medicines available in all government hospitals of the
state and to set up government-aided medical stores across the state.
Government of Chhattisgarh has cracked down on nine private doctors and
suspended their registration for allegedly advising and removing of uterus and
both ovaries without any convincing medical reasons.
Controversy
The nephrologist involved in the court case about the death
of Seema Rai (which was referred to as a case of medical negligence by Major
Pankaj Rai in the episode), Dr. Rajanna Sreedhara, stated that his legal
counsel and Fortis Hospital, where he worked, were preparing to send a legal
notice to Khan and the show producers for libel. He accused Khan of failing to
do a proper research, and retired Army Major Pankaj Rai of falsely accusing him
of causing his wife's death through medical negligence. Sreedhara appealed on
IBN Live and social networking forums for a chance to tell his side of the
story. He claimed that Rai was harassing him for the past two years for a crime
he had not committed, and that the show had ruined his reputation as a
respected physician. On reading Sreedhara's transcript defending himself, Rai
wrote an open letter to IBNLive, and provided several supporting medical and
legal documents. He stated that the doctor had not presented the facts
correctly, and that he was "fighting a lone legal battle with limited
resources against a mighty corporation."
5. Intolerance to
Love Love marriages and Honor killings in India
The fifth episode focused on unacceptability of love marriage in Indian culture, and also threw the limelight on honor killing in the country. The show showcased some real life examples where a couple married against their families' wishes and had to leave their loved ones and of honor killing. The first case saw a couple; Lokendra and Fehmida from Uttar Pradesh, who have been struggling to save their life from the latter's family despite a protection order from court, which is proving them helpless. The next case was of 27 year old from Kolkata; Rizwanur Rahman, who lost his life in an attempt to marry a Hindu girl Priyanka Todi, daughter of industrialist Ashok Todi. The episode then showcased the story of Manoj-Babli honour killing case from Haryana, both of whom were killed for having a love marriage. Manoj’s mother and sister have been , often being threatened number of times to withdraw the complaint. Aamir then had an interaction with Khap Panchayat, a religious caste-based council having no judicial powers. The panchayat claimed Manoj and Babli marriage to be immoral, however added that they didn’t deserve to be killed.
Sanjay Sachdev, Chairman of Love Commandos from New Delhi
was invited for the episode as a guest. His committee helps believes in the
motto, "Love shall conquer the world", and thus helps couples by
giving them basic necessities and legal help. The last story was of Alka and
Uday, both doctor by profession. Alka's parents refrained themselves for a long
time from accepting their daughter's marriage due to the fear of social stigma.
Her parents realized that their daughter's happiness weighed more than social
stigma and accepted the marriage. The show ended up with a song "Ghar Yaad
Aata Hai Mujhe" sung by Sona Mohapatra and Ram Sampath.
Aftermath
Haryana's khap panchayats, known for their bizarre diktats,
have now demanded that Aamir Khan's popular TV show, Satyamev Jayate, be pulled
off air. Aamir drew the ire of the kangaroo courts after he accused them of
triggering honour killings.
.jpg)
.jpg)
6. Persons with disabilities Physical
Disabilities 10 June 2012
The sixth episode focused on the social problems faced by
those with disabilities.
In the show, Aamir Highlighted the hardships faced by the
disabled who even today continue to struggle for their basic rights. People
with disabilities are no different than regular people when it comes to the
zeal and appreciation for life.
India has to decide whether it wants the crores of people
with disabilities to stay at home, or to be a part of the mainstream and
contribute to the economy.
Circumstances led Dr Rajendra Johar to be confined to the
bed, and he was declared disabled. But he has turned the very notion of
disability on its head, and from his bed has helped countless people with
disability to gain education, employment and self-respect. Dr Johar is the
founder of the NGO Family of Disabled
Pratibha Chaturvedi is Shreya’s mother — and her best
friend. “She calls me ‘dost’,” giggles the cute little girl, who is affected by
cerebral palsy but wants to lighten the burden on her mom’s life. “Sometimes
she gets so tired and I press her feet,” says Shreya.
Shreya Chaturvedi is 11 and exudes an enviable zest for
life. Another person with disability is Sai Prasad, who demonstrates similar
enthusiasm, and he has taken flight, literally. Software engineer Krishnakant
Mane writes poetry in his spare time, and climbs real mountains as well as the
virtual ones created by a disabled-unfriendly world. “
Another person with disability is Sai Prasad, who
demonstrates similar enthusiasm, and he has taken flight, literally. Software
engineer Krishnakant Mane writes poetry in his spare time, and climbs real
mountains as well as the virtual ones created by a disabled-unfriendly world.
Sai Prasad found the country’s infrastructural disability to be more
challenging than his own. He saw a world of difference in the facilities for
the disabled in the United States compared to what we have in India.
And the Song of the Show, Chanda, Awesome performance by
Differently abled people.
7. Danger at home Domestic
Violence 17 June 2012
.jpg)
The seventh episode deals with the serious issue of Domestic
violence. This episode had a majority of male audience. The show started with
Aamir khan asking audience on their view about unsafe place for women. There
were many different views regarding this. All the views from audience pointed
to a public place. Aamir Khan contradicted this by first showing his findings
about the patents statistics in a hospital located in Bandra, Mumbai.
The show then proceeded with interview with some ladies
affected by domestic violence.
In this episode, Aamir Khan had promised Shanno, a female
cab driver who was a victim of domestic violence that he would hire her vehicle
whenever he would visit Delhi next. So when the actor arrived in the Capital
for two days (to present his research on medical malpractices in Parliament),
he hired a cab from Sakha, the agency that Shanno works with.
8. Poison on our Plate Pesticide poisoning
and Organic farming
The show highlighted the adverse effect of pesticides on
people's health and the environment. Examples of toxic chemicals entering the
human food chain through spraying of chemicals by farmers were given. It also
demonstrated new farming techniques which do not support spraying of any
chemicals such as pesticides and fungicides. Organic Farming techniques and success
story of a farmer were also showed.
The show was started with a brief on a small research that
was carried out by a doctor on how dangerously high dose of chemicals found in
pesticides are entering infants through breast feeding mothers.
Then a small documentary was shown on how some villages in
the Kasaragod District of Kerala got affected by repeated unscientific spraying
of pesticides using helicopter for a continuous period of 25 years, between
1976 and 2000. Then a doctor who served the same village described the plights
of the people, on how they fought and ended this. He gave evidence that the
mortality rate during pregnancy had decreased significantly as a result of not
using pesticides.
The show then discussed on alternatives to pesticides free
farming. Aamir Khan talked to Sikkim's Chief Minister, Pawan Chamling, about
Sikkim imposing a total ban on chemical pesticides and fungicides. Sikkim is
the first state in India aiming to convert all its farms to use organic farming
practices. Another example of organic farming reform in Andra Pradesh was also
highlighted.
There was also counter part view by a MD of a leading
pesticide company. who said that the adverse use of pesticide is exaggerated.
At the end of the show, Aamir Khan had general discussion
with the audience on this topic. The show ended with Aamir Khan asking viewers
to vote on their views on government encouraging organic farming.
9. Think before you Drink Alcohol abuse 1 July 2012
.jpg)
The show highlighted the issue of alcoholism in Indian
society. The audience of the show were the group of people who were under 30
years. Most of them at some point of their life had been under the influence of
alcohol. Some thought it to be a social necessity and some took it to celebrate
some occasion.
The show started with Aamir khan inviting a reputed news
editor to the show. The guest is very successful in his professional career now
but ten years back his condition was not the same. He narrated on how he lost
his family life, social reputation , financial stability under the influence of
alcohol.
The show then proceeded with inviting a psychiatrist who
explained on how alcohol effects the person's life.
Other guest to the show were Javed Akhtar, who was also
under the influence of alcoholism at one point in his life. He also narrated on
how he never touched it for past 21 years.
10.Dignity for All Casteism
and Untouchability 8 July 2012
.jpg)
The show discussed the social ills of casteism and
untouchability. Aamir and the guests spoke about discrimination made in Indian
society on the basis of caste, and the kind of treatment that is meted out to
people belong to the Dalit community. Though untouchability is a criminal
offence in India, and the state has, since independence, adopted affirmative
action for the benefit of backward castes, incidents of caste based
discrimination are reported from across the country on an everyday basis.
The first guest to speak on the topic was Dr Kaushal Panwar,
a Sanskrit professor with Delhi University. Dr Panwar, who belongs to the Dalit
community, faced caste based discrimination right from her childhood and
continues to face prejudice even today. She talked about her early childhood
and her first brush with casteism when she was asked to wear a different
uniform to differentiate her based on her caste. The prejudice continued right
through her childhood and did not stop even after she joined the elite
Jawaharlal Nehru University. Even though Dr Panwar is now a professor in one of
India's best universities, she is time and again made to feel inferior because
of her caste. Despite facing enormous hardships, Dr Panwar was determined to
challenge the existent social norms. It was her will and her father's constant
encouragement that made her the person that she is now.
The show then featured Balwant Singh, a Dalit and a former
bureaucrat, who resigned from the Indian Administrative Service after facing
regular humiliation, even from his subordinates. The discrimination is so
deep-rooted that even elected Members of Parliament are rendered helpless. PL
Punia, Chairman of the National Commission for Scheduled Castes, recollected
how priests of the Kali temple in Orissa locked up the sanctum sanctorum when
he tried opening up the temple gates for Dalits.
The second guest on the show was documentary filmmaker
Stalin K, who has produced a film titled ‘India Untouched’. He cleared the
misconception that casteism is not only prevalent among the Hindus, but is
apparent among the Muslims, Christians and Sikhs too. Aamir showed a few clips
from Stalin’s documentary to show the prevalent practice of caste based
discrimination across religious lines. Stalin advocated inter-caste marriages
as a possible solution to end this ill, which runs deep in the Indian psyche.
Next story to feature on the show was from Samarthpura
village in Rajasthan, where a Dalit, Rampal Suwasiya, challenged the exclusive
right of upper castes to ride a horse during wedding processions. Facing
threats, Rampal approached the Station House Officer (SHO) of the nearest
police station. The SHO, Manvendra Singh Chauhan, despite belonging to an upper
caste himself, decided to uphold the law of the land. The wedding procession
was provided police protection and a regressive social custom was eventually
broken.
The show then played host to Justice CS Dharmadhikari, a
veteran freedom fighter and former judge. Born in a Brahmin family, Justice
Dharmadhikari disassociated himself from the customary practices followed by
his community, for which he suffered social exclusion from other members of his
caste. He narrated an incident when his nephew’s life got saved by a Dalit
person’s blood. He raised an important question to everyone - When the blood of
a Brahmin and a Dalit is not different by virtue of their castes, why is the
society hell bent on segregating people on the basis of their birth? Justice
Dharmadhikari emphasised that the only way to stop caste-based discrimination
is to refuse the existence of a caste system. He received a standing ovation
from the audience.
The last guest on the show was Bezwada Wilson, son of a
manual scavenger who took upon himself to create awareness against this inhuman
occupation and uplift people who were “traditionally” into the occupation. It
was due to his, and his team's effort, that the Indian government eventually
passed the the 'Employment of Manual Scavengers and Construction of Dry Latrines
(Prohibition) Act, 1993'.The implementation of this act, however, has been
unsatisfactory. Wilson accused the Indian Railways of employing manual
scavengers to clean up railway tracks on platforms.
The general consensus on the show was that casteism can only
be eradicated if both the backward and the forward communities join hands
together. The issue needs to be acknowledged and dealt with on an urgent basis.
Real development of the nation can only take place if citizens treat each other
equally and do not consider any person inferior on the basis of birth.
The audience question of the episode was - "Do we wish
to see an immediate end to the practice of manual scavenging, or cleaning of
others' excreta by hand?" The charity proceeds from the episode will be
given to 'Association for Rural and Urban Needy', a society working for the
welfare of manual scavengers.
The show ended with the song 'Kabir Vani', Kabir's poetry
rendered into lyrics by Munna Dhiman, set to music by Ram Sampath and sung by
Keerthi Sagathia.
Reception
The show did not generate as much interest as some of the
earlier episodes. Part of it could be because the issue of casteism is not a
topic unknown to most Indians. Some people alleged that the show generalised
the entire Brahmin community of being casteist. Others felt the episode was
long and the lack of intensity made for dull viewing. The show was, however, by
and large, well appreciated for bringing the topic of casteism and
untouchability up for discussion on mainstream television.
11. Sunset Years, Sunshine Life Old age 15 July 2012
.jpg)
12. Every Drop Counts Water crisis and Rainwater harvesting 22 July 2012
.jpg)
